Yes, switching companies is often the fastest way to increase your salary, but it comes with higher risk. The reason is that external offers are based on what companies are currently willing to pay to fill a role, while internal raises are usually capped by fixed budgets and pay structures.
Table of Contents
Why do people usually get bigger raises by switching companies?
Switching companies often leads to bigger pay increases because new hires are priced based on current hiring demand. When companies need to fill a role quickly or are competing for candidates, they raise offers to secure talent.
This creates upward pressure on salaries for external hires. Your pay is determined by what the market is willing to offer right now, not what you were earning before.
That is why switching can reset your compensation to match current demand.
Why are internal raises usually smaller?
Internal raises are smaller because they are tied to annual review cycles where increases are typically capped at a fixed percentage. Managers operate within budgets and pay bands, which limits how much they can adjust salaries.
This system is designed to keep compensation consistent across teams and control costs. Even strong performers often receive incremental raises unless they are promoted.
The result is steady but slower income growth compared to switching.
When does switching companies make the most sense?
Switching makes the most sense when your current pay is significantly below what similar roles are paying elsewhere. In this case, staying can lock you into a lower salary baseline.
This often happens early in careers when initial offers are below market rate. Athena B. left a role after realizing her compensation did not match expectations and moved into a better-paying position shortly after.
Switching in this situation is less about strategy and more about correcting underpayment.
Why can switching companies be risky?
Switching companies is risky because the new environment is uncertain until you are inside. Performance expectations, team dynamics, and job security are not fully visible during the hiring process.
If the role does not work out, it can take time to find another opportunity. Isabel K. left a role expecting a smoother transition but spent a long period doing temporary work before re-entering her field.
The potential pay increase can be meaningful, but the risk is losing stable income if the move does not work out.
When is it better to stay at the same company?
Staying can be better when your current role offers strong long-term benefits or a clear path to promotion. Compensation includes more than salary, and leaving too early can mean giving up future value.
Stock options, retirement matching, and internal promotions can significantly increase total earnings over time. Tess I. chose to stay partly because of strong retirement matching and stock incentives that would compound over time.
In these cases, short-term pay increases from switching may not outweigh long-term gains.
What actually determines whether switching will increase your salary?
Switching increases your salary when there is a gap between what you earn now and what companies are currently willing to pay for your role. The larger the gap, the larger the potential increase.
This depends on:
- How in-demand your skills are
- How underpaid you are relative to similar roles
- Whether companies are actively hiring for your role
Data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that wage growth varies significantly depending on job changes and labor demand, with workers who move roles often seeing faster pay adjustments than those who stay.
If the gap is small, switching may not change much. If it is large, switching can result in a meaningful increase.
If you are deciding whether to stay or switch, the key is understanding how much companies are currently willing to pay for your role compared to what you are earning now.
GradSimple Insiders is the first Career Intelligence membership for early professionals who are unsure what to do next and want to avoid wasting years on the wrong path. We break down real hiring data and job market trends twice a month so you can see which entry-level roles are actually in demand, which industries are slowing down, and whether a career path is worth pursuing before making a long-term decision.
